The Montana Standard
Contact Us | RSS | Make MTstandard.com your homepage | Careers in Lee | e-Edition | Mobile
 
46°F
The Montana Standard

Petersen plea agreement does community a disservice

Letter to the Editor

By The Montana Standard Staff - 10/15/2008

A travesty of justice has occurred in the plea agreement proposed in the Wade Petersen case.

Even though the prosecution has a strong case against Petersen, prosecutors felt the need to strike a plea agreement that offers very little for holding Petersen accountable for his actions. One might argue that a plea was in the best interest of everyone involved; the only "best interest" served by this plea is Petersen's.

Petersen has put everyone through a tough year, denying any responsibility for his actions. Now he is willing to plead guilty to the charges in exchange for a very lenient sentence — and the right to have a gun. A girl is dead and he is worried about going hunting!

I am not heartless or unsympathetic in viewing this matter. It is sad that a 20-year-old made such a horrible choice. What is sadder is that Petersen still has not shown any responsibility or remorse for the results of those actions.

Petersen's actions were not a slight error in judgment. A young girl lost her life. Two other young girls' lives have been changed forever; they have endured physical and emotional pain and damage.

The bottom line is that Petersen broke the law that night, not once — but several times. Petersen hit three innocent girls, left them lying in the street for someone else to find — or hit again, and lied about doing it! Yet prosecutors still felt it necessary to cut a "sweetheart deal." Neither the families nor the community have been served well by that plea agreement. While a stiffer sentence will not bring Mariah back nor heal the others, the message this plea agreement is sending is break the law, repeatedly, and get a slap on the wrist.

The victims in this case will serve the real sentence. Under the proposed plea, Petersen will be out hunting in a very short time while the Okrusch, Kilmer and McCarthy families will be spending the next several years picking up the pieces of their lives.

If I were cynical, I would almost think that prosecutors Eileen Joyce and Samm Cox are more interested in running for county attorney than trying a difficult case. If this is the best they can do, then neither deserves our vote in November.

I hope the judge rejects or modifies the plea to make it meaningful.

MaryAnn Alexander 2900 Hannibal St.

Butte


Civil Dialogue:show/hide -13 comment(s)-
The site mtstandard.com provides this community forum for readers to exchange ideas and opinions on the news of the day. Passionate views, pointed criticism and critical thinking are welcome. Name-calling, crude language and personal abuse are not welcome. Moderators will monitor comments with an eye toward maintaining a high level of civility in this forum. If you don't see your comment, perhaps... more










TOP JOBS






Make us your homepage | Subscribe | Archives | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy

Copyright © The Montana Standard; a division of Lee Enterprises
Copyright © 2008 Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Regional Lee Papers : Helena | Billings | Missoula | The Adit | Prairie Star | MT Magazine | Ravalli | Bismarck | Mini Nickel - Bozeman